'Vicissitudes of life': Woman loses lawsuit against private-hire driver who braked to avoid crossing chicken

asiaone.com · politics

Why did the chicken cross the road?While there could be many possibilities and witty responses to the classic question, one such incident on Holland Road on Feb 19, 2024, led to a lawsuit between a woman passenger and her private-hire vehicle driver.The claimant, Yvonne Chen Qianyun, sued for injuries sustained when her driver braked to avoid a collision.In dismissing the suit and ordering her to pay costs of $15,000, District Judge Jonathan Ng noted that Chen was an "innocent passenger", but found that the driver, Tan Teng Kiat, did not breach the standard of care required of him.And while Chen said the chicken was on the road, Tan said the chicken had flown across the road.Judge Ng wrote in his grounds of decision dated Nov 18 that this difference was immaterial, pointing out that what was material and undisputed was the chicken's act on crossing the road that caused the vehicle in front to brake.Tan, in turn, similarly applied brakes, which caused Chen's injuries and brought about the claim.Her claim was premised on the fact that Tan had breached the standard of care required of him.

Read full article → Compare