KOMMENTAR - Die Tech-Szene diskutiert, ob KI-Modelle «Schmerzen» empfinden, wenn sie «gefoltert» werden. Das ist absurd

nzz.ch · world
Full story

A debate over whether AI models feel pain when they are 'tortured' has been going around tech circles, and one commentator has had enough of it. The reasoning offered is plain: a language model deserves no feelings, and inventing suffering for it confuses software with a living thing. Chatting with a bot for hours about cruel scenarios does not hurt the machine, which has no capacity to be hurt. The only damage falls on the person doing the prompting, whose own imagination supplies all the distress involved. Models predict text; they experience nothing, no matter how convincingly they write about pain. Worrying about machine suffering distracts from questions that actually matter, such as how these systems are used on people. The closing demand is simple: let the machine stay a machine.

Wir dürfen KI-Modellen keine Gefühle andichten. Wer mit KI stundenlang über grausame Szenarien chattet, schadet höchstens sich selbst. Ein Plädoyer dafür, die Maschine Maschine sein zu lassen.

Read full article → Compare