Political parties and civic groups in South Africa's eThekwini municipality are split over the alliance between the March and March Movement and Voice of Phoenix. Supporters appear to accept the partnership, while critics have raised questions about the extent of consultation. Some opponents are also challenging Voice of Phoenix's registration status. The dispute has turned what was presented as a partnership into a contested political arrangement. Although the organisations remain linked, opposition parties and civic groups are using the controversy to challenge the alliance's credibility. Until those concerns are addressed, the partnership appears vulnerable to wider division within eThekwini politics.